Navigation

  • What's the Guru Gonna Say Next? Subscribe now.

    RSS 2.0 | Atom 1.0 | CDF

    TopRank Reader Poll

    Search

    Categories

     

    On this page

    The World's Longest On-Going Circular Debate
    Kudos to SEO-Scoop
    SEO IS DEAD --- Or Is It?
    What's the Point of Blogging Anyway?

    Archive

    Blogroll

    Debra Mastaler
    The Absolute Authority In Link Building for Market Share.
     Fantomaster. A true legend in his own time.
    One of the most intelligent men I have ever had the pleasure of knowing. And quite a looker too in that expensive suit he always wears in public
     Jim Boynkin
    a true in-the-trenches SEO warrior
    Search Engine Optimization Journal
    For their obvious good taste.
    SearchRank Blog
    David Wallace nominated me for an award and I like him !
     SEO Rock Stars
    These are just some of the people I have had the great fortune of meeting, doing business with or just read them all the time because they are either good or entertaining or both. Just do a search for any of these names. Todd Malicoat- Michael Gray- John Andrews- Ed Purkiss- Danny Sullivan - Christine Churchill - Kim Krause- Jenifer Slegg - Jason Duke - Mikkel Svendsen -Ian Mcanerin and more. I wish I could name them al
     Shoemoney
    I don't know of anyone else who has lost so much and gained so much doing it. A man who puts his money where his mouth is.
     Sphinn
    Everybody is doing it!
     Superior SEO insight
    This guy can really open your eyes to the REAL seo world with every post. Excellent!
    Talkndu
    News and Information about Mobile SEO
    The best search news site
    If you can only read one search news site a day searchengineland should be it. Then go Sphinn it!
     This Week in SEO
    Another cool resource to help you remain out standing in your field. Great job guys!
     Wolf-Howl
    the must read blog of a true SEO linking artist

    Disclaimer
    The opinions expressed herein are my own personal opinions and do not represent my employer's view in anyway.

    Send mail to the author(s) E-mail

    Total Posts: 71
    This Year: 0
    This Month: 0
    This Week: 0
    Comments: 400

    Sign In

     Sunday, June 29, 2008
    Sunday, June 29, 2008 4:58:52 PM (Eastern Standard Time, UTC-05:00) ( )

    Question for the Week of June 28th, 2008

    What don't you trust about SEO (search engine optimization)? ... and why?

    Someone at Linkedin asked this questions AGAIN! www.linkedin.com/answers/marketing-sales/advertising-promotion/internet-marketing/MAR_ADP_INM/257887-517478?split_page=2

    For 11 years I've seen this single question and ensuing circular debate asked over and over and over and always with the exact same outcome. No winners on either side of the argument. Surely I can't be the only one who wonders why there is NEVER an answer if the same questions gets asked again and again. If  any of us truly longed for logic and the rule of reason to dictate the direction of our industry going forward as a profession, then doesn't it seem strange to that no resolution seems to lie in sight?

    If two plus two equals 4 and we can all agree to that, and if we can all look at a rose and agree that it really is a rose, then why does a resolution to this little poser elude us? Why can we not define SEO, all agree that it is what it is and move on?

    For reference and for those who may not hold a linkedin account, (does such a beast exist?),  here is the questions offered this time:

    SEO is a fundamental aspect of making your website relevant to your visitors and prospects. The major search engines have SEO consultants on staff because it is so critical to effective paid placement. Yet, there are many examples of genuine disdain being expressed for SEO on LinkedIn as though it is a false promise rather than a business tool. Why?

    Clarification added 5 days ago:

    Optimization is essential to an effective paid placement (SEM) campaign because of the importance of relevance. If your SEM matrix is not properly relevant (you are bidding on the phrase "Toyota" when you are selling "Ford") you will pay more for a click. This CAN be optimized, but not easily. A proper optimization WILL reduce the CPC and the major search engines encourage this practice and will even help you do it.


    Granted this one does have a new twist with the "clarification" that threw even the Guru for a loop. It seems to never fail that when somone adds some clarification, you can bet your ass that any point with even a remote link to reality can now be clearly hidden behind a thick veil of clarity. Be that as it may, the gist remains the same.

    Anyway --- I digest, so let's get back to the point.

    Linkedin is probably my favorite of the social media experiments borne of Web 2.0 but I just don't seem to have the time these days so I don't get by there often. I was lead there by Kim Krause who happens to be one of those people I try to MAKE time for http://cre8pc.com/blog/index.php and after reading the entire thread, (what a waste --- AGAIN), I posted and instead of trying to "clarify that statement, I'll just post it here so I can get some placements out of it.
    ****************************************************************************************************************
    We're all over-thinking the problem. There is disdain for SEO for the simple fact it does not exist. We are not discussing clients hiring people to optimize search engines now are we. That fact alone makes it impossible to define in a way we can all agree with, yet it continues to be bought and sold.

    There IS such a thing as online business development. there is such a thing as online traffic generation, website optimization for improved functionality or increased conversions and there is such a thing as public relations and brand building.

    Go to people who specialize and advertise in these types of services and you can set verifiable targets and metrics that can be gauged. You can set specific requirements and I can deliver specific results, thereby establishing a market that governs itself much like any other 'real" business with value based on verifiable return rather than solely on percieved supply and demand.

    You may say, but there is verifiable return with SEO and I would argue if there is, then that is business development and any association with SEO is coincidental at best, totally irrelevant at worst.

    As long as we continue to discuss a business process as SEO , no one really understand what they are buying OR selling yet it keeps being bought and sold while both buyer and seller tries to "explain" a process that does not exist.
    *****************************************

    I understand the need to cling to a label you've become familiar with. I do it too so I'm not trying to call any one out or suggest I have a "better" opinion than others. If I offend I apologize because that is truly not my intent. I say what I'm saying because I honestly believe it to be the truth and I say it in the spirit of contributing to a positive change in the industry, on the web, and in myself.

    Peace Y'all


    G





    Just curious, but am I the only one that used to bite the heads and limbs off of my army men to represent the dead and wounded?
    I got a Cowboy and Indian set
    called Fort Apache for a Xmas present one year. It was pretty cool because it had three sides and two gun towers with a real swinging gate. Later that Xmas day I decided I needed a headless horse that one of the Indians had been riding but now had a chewed stump where the head used to be. But it took me like 5 minutes to chew through the horse's neck.

    As a result, most of the supporting livestock and thick pieces of artillery from future fantasy battles survived.





     


     

    | | # 
     Monday, June 23, 2008
    Monday, June 23, 2008 4:18:28 PM (Eastern Standard Time, UTC-05:00) ( )

    I meant to say something about this quite sometime back and it just slipped my mind but I believe a little cyber pat on the back is in order for Donna Fontenot and SEO-Scoop http://www.seo-scoop.com


    I guess i first realized that Donna was a notch above most SEO bloggers when i realized the effort she put in to publish the post Hundreds of SEO Interviews. http://www.seo-scoop.com/2006/08/25/75-seo-interviews/ That list was not scraped or borrowed. That was an original idea that she was willing to put her own elbow grease to and offered up a valuable resource to the online marketing community and the web in general.

    I've always believed she deserved a LOT more credit for that effort than she ever got and I feel remiss in not mentioning it sooner.

    Ovet the past couple of years I've seen her do several tribute and compilation pieces and all of them original and none of them easy to do without putting in a lot of time and work. They are original and represent a true desire to contribute something of quality. I appreciate that and think that kind of effort should be applauded.

    Her latest that caught my eye and again impressed me with how much work she puts into her blog was her post Search Bloggers http://www.seo-scoop.com/2008/06/17/search-bloggers/ where she has compiled a list of 58 bloggers who pretty much represent a who's who of search bloggers. Anyone wanting to get the "scoop" on the latest in the industry now has a one stop shop for finding the straight dope on the industry.

    I think the web is a better place with Donna Fontenot and SEO-Scoop on it.


    Peace Y'all

    G


    Laissez Les Bon Temps Roulez


    | | # 
     Tuesday, June 17, 2008
    Tuesday, June 17, 2008 12:01:56 AM (Eastern Standard Time, UTC-05:00) ( )

    Question for the Week of June 15th, 2008

    Hey guru, there is a lot of controversy over at sphinn about whether or not SEO is dead. What do you think? Is seo history?

    *****************************************

    I assume you are referring to the sphinn post at http://sphinn.com/story/52207. I followed that to the article at Search Engine Journal http://www.searchenginejournal.com/false-prophecy-onsite-seo-will-be-history/7092/  and then that lead me to the post at Marketing Pilgrim by Asif Anwar named 13 Prophecies of Internet Marketing

    The first prophecy in the list of 13 was titled Prophecy #1: Onsite Search Engine Optimization (SEO) will be History.

    As to be expected this set off the heated round of posts at Sphinn.

    Personally, I enjoy posts such as Asif’s because it was well written, not your usual seo fodder and obviously he’s a smart man,(assuming he is of the male persuasion), and had put some thought into the post. Posts like that are thought provoking and I believe whether I agree or not, it is good to “think” about things from a different perspective.

    {NOTE: I especially enjoyed him stating that SEO's do optimize search engines, the engineers do. I thought I was the only one preaching that sermon.}

    That being said I can certainly see how people who have dedicated significant resources to promoting themselves as SEO’s would feel threatened and take offense. I don’t blame them for taking up the sword but there is really no need to worry or feel threatened.

    If a list has value someone is willing to pay to be on top

    You can call it serps or organic results but whatever it is called it is nothing more than a list. A list that has the power to deliver targeted prospects based on a referrer and that has value.

    Anytime there is any kind of list that represents either tangible or aesthetic value to more than one person, there will be those willing to sacrifice to be on top of that list. That means there is an opportunity of profit to all those willing to apply themselves to learn how the order of that list is determined and how to at least offer the perception of possessing the ability to influence the outcome of that list.  

    So, I believe that the possibility of the components of the value proposition of online marketing may change dramatically, AND peril may lay in wait for those that refuse to acknowledge those changes, as long as there are search engines results delivered, (be it organic or PPC, personalized or human edited), there will be those willing to pay dearly to those who can offer an advantage over their competitors of gaining the most benefit from the value represented by those results.

    On site SEO may be history at some point. Maybe the Asif guy is right. WHO CARES?

    What do we care if it is on site, off site, social or astral physical suppositories?? As long as we continue to study, experiment, discuss and consider how to manipulate the list to favor our clients and our objectives, we have jobs. Well paying jobs at that.

    We’ve already seen drastic changes in the industry. From on site, to off site to social media, blended search and now moving into personalized.  Some have prospered while others have given up and moved on. Some have been right and some have been wrong but through it all,

     

    THE PRICE JUST KEEPS GOING UP!

     

    PEACE Y’ALL!

    G

     

     

    Boy, if you’ve sat in my car playin that radio till my batry run down, I’m gonna bust your behind!

     

     

     

    | | # 
     Monday, June 02, 2008
    Monday, June 02, 2008 10:50:18 AM (Eastern Standard Time, UTC-05:00) ( )

    What's the Point of Blogging Anyway?

    I probably ask myself that question just about every time I sit down and get ready to write a post. Most of the time I'm so busy I feel like a one-eyed dog in a sausage factory and I don't know which way to turn. Most days it's very difficult to stop the whirlwind that is an SEO's life and focus on a single topic long enough to write something that I feel offers something useful, informative, educational or at least entertaining.

    From the first day I slid in an AOL disc that I got in the mail, (now those guys knew how to spam!), and found out what a chat room was, I knew that once you hit that enter button that you were no longer in control of your own words. I knew you couldn't take back anything stupid you said and that your stupid remark would likely be inerasably preserved to posterity.

    One of my favorite quotes is:

    Small words spoken in truth can sway the minds of nations. But I don't care who you are, keep talking long enough and you're going to say something stupid.

    So, believing in the quote and realizing the potential shelf life of stored electronic data, almost from my first day online I have always tried to choose my words very carefully before I hit that enter button. I rarely post much of anywhere to keep my averages down but when I do it usually takes me quite a bit of time to make even a short post, (I'm not sure I've ever made one of those?), because I'll read what I wrote over and over again trying to check for grammar and context until I'm pretty darn sure I'm saying exactly what I want to say.

    That philosophy has paid off well for me because my total number of posts to stupid ratio is relatively low.

    Blogging is different than community contributions on forums, social sites and other people's blogs. Why do we blog when to do it well enough for anyone to give a crap it takes focus, dedication and no small degree of time-consuming effort?

    Is it to increase revenues? A kind of back handed advertisement disguised as valuable content? Is it just to hear the sounds of our own fingers clicking the keyboard hoping someone sphinns our egos? Are we trying to share our wisdom and vision with those less wise and far-seeing? Or is it really motivated by a simple desire to want to help or fellow man to gain the benefit of our experience without any expectation of compensation other than just the warm and fuzzies associated with feeling like we really are a good person?

    I don't really think it matters. I think quality is quality regardless of the motivation. I think knowledge and insight lie at our feet like small pebbles or blades of grass with each one offering some degree of cerebral reward  if we are willing to take the time to look close enough.

    I recently had the pleasure of engaging in a discussion with Aaron Wall in the SEObook community forums, community.seobook.com. (I can't provide a link to the specific post because it is for paid members only BUT I can tell you it is a special kind of community and well worth the cost of membership.) Anyway, I gave a review of a product that was being discussed and I wanted to point out that I had worked with the creator of the product and knew the gap between what he was selling and what he actually did. Aaron replied with:

    This is actually one of the hardest parts about being me in the SEO industry...I hear so much dirt about virtually everyone.

    The core of it is that many people cloak, buy links, etc. and then make it sound like all of their success was organic. It seems after people get to a certain level of success hypocrisy is ok because everyone else does it, or we get selective amnesia. At the end of the day everyone is pandering for
    http://community.seobook.com/images/smilies/money.gif 

    **************************

    I initially thought Aaron a little young for that kind of cynicism but it got to me thinking. I at first wanted to argue and then realized that it didn't really matter. Maybe he's right or maybe he has just become jaded from being him in the industry. Either way, his insight into internet marketing has been invaluable to me personally and I believe to the entire global SEO community. I could say the same of literally dozens, maybe hundreds of others in the industry who could convincingly argue from one day to the next that they were just trying to make a buck, or just trying to build a name for themselves or they were just unselfishly trying to help their fellow man. Whatever their reason, the fact remains that it is the quality of the content that is the dominant value and not the motivation. Of course value is subjective.

    For myself, I have been guilty at one time or another, of pushing the envelope from one end of the scale to the other. I need to make a buck, I need to build a name for myself and I truly wish to help others, (when convenient of course). But one thing I have ALWAYS tried to do regardless of purpose, I have always tried to be honest and honestly try to impart something of value to the people who would give me their time and trust in everything I do in my business and in my personal life. (Actually, I don’t have a business AND personal life. They are one and the same.)  

    That is a lofty goal and there have been times I have made horrendous mistakes and fell short of the mark but I think in all things human, the aim and the willingness to accept mistakes, learn from them and re-commit to doing better is about the best any of us could hope for.

    So after revealing my basic philosophy with all it's flaws and gaps from ideals to reality, you can probably see why writing a blog can become extremely stressful for someone who has that damn perfection streak in him that makes him unable to throw crap and gibberish out there without forethought and  serious consideration. The crap and gibberish I throw has been carefully considered and sometimes even forethought wasn't enough and I took it all the way to fivethought.

    There have been so many times I had to get behind schedule simply because I could not bring myself to post when I had no clear idea of what I could say to justify the time. So many times I've considered just giving it up because I didn't see where it benefited anybody. Not me or anyone reading. Then ever so often, once in a blue moon, something happens and I'm reminded of why I do it.

    I'm reminded why anyone does it when I consider that most of you who have been doing the blogging thing longer than I has had the same type of thing happen. THIS is why we do it or at least why we should do it.

    This is a comment left on one of my posts I wanted to share.
    ************************

    Hi Bob.  Even though I don't understand much of anything about concepts of SEO, I must say the articles that you've written that I've had the pleasure to read so far have made a huge impression on me.  Beneath all the technical terms and advice (which are often a bit overwhelming and confusing to a total newbie like me), the insights that you offered go beyond online marketing and computer talk.  I especially liked the way you used stories, whether from your experience as a former salesman at a store or dealing with heating/air conditioning repairmen, you taught lessons about human nature, the value of hard work, and the use of reasoning skills to solve problems.  Reading your articles made me reflect about where I am at the current stage of my life.  It got me thinking about my strengths and weaknesses, my past successes and disappointments, and those things that I still desire that I have not yet achieved.  For thing to be better, I must become better.  There is no short cut to success. Thank you for your wisdom and for planting seeds of change in my head. 

    Your friend, George

    Comments page: http://massa.techndu.com/CommentView,guid,0A9E2543-37BD-436A-951C-D114D9AFA87C.aspx

    **************************************

    WOW! I don't think I have ever had a nicer compliment from anyone and I don't know if this person saying that will make me any money or get my name known or even if it really will do anything to help him. I just know that this kind of exchange is the way the web SHOULD be.

    The web is going to be commercial. There are bad things in the world. Everyday is not going to be good for everybody BUT, if we all took just a little time to get other people to say things like this to you and to say these kind of things to those who have made you feel better or taught you something, the web and the world would be a better place. And that is worth blogging for.


    At the very least, remember that there are people actually giving you their time and you have an honest responsibility to them. Your words, your actions and your re-actions do matter. You have the power through your words to contribute value, to change minds and to have an impact on the entire world. Pretty awesome when you stop and think about it huh?

    Peace y'all

    G

     

     



    don't forget to say your prayers for ya git inta bed baby.

    | | #