Navigation

  • What's the Guru Gonna Say Next? Subscribe now.

    RSS 2.0 | Atom 1.0 | CDF

    TopRank Reader Poll

    Search

    Categories

     

    On this page

    The Anti-SEO SEO Guru Asks -- Can You Define SEO?

    Archive

    Blogroll

    Debra Mastaler
    The Absolute Authority In Link Building for Market Share.
     Fantomaster. A true legend in his own time.
    One of the most intelligent men I have ever had the pleasure of knowing. And quite a looker too in that expensive suit he always wears in public
     Jim Boynkin
    a true in-the-trenches SEO warrior
    Search Engine Optimization Journal
    For their obvious good taste.
    SearchRank Blog
    David Wallace nominated me for an award and I like him !
     SEO Rock Stars
    These are just some of the people I have had the great fortune of meeting, doing business with or just read them all the time because they are either good or entertaining or both. Just do a search for any of these names. Todd Malicoat- Michael Gray- John Andrews- Ed Purkiss- Danny Sullivan - Christine Churchill - Kim Krause- Jenifer Slegg - Jason Duke - Mikkel Svendsen -Ian Mcanerin and more. I wish I could name them al
     Shoemoney
    I don't know of anyone else who has lost so much and gained so much doing it. A man who puts his money where his mouth is.
     Sphinn
    Everybody is doing it!
     Superior SEO insight
    This guy can really open your eyes to the REAL seo world with every post. Excellent!
    Talkndu
    News and Information about Mobile SEO
    The best search news site
    If you can only read one search news site a day searchengineland should be it. Then go Sphinn it!
     This Week in SEO
    Another cool resource to help you remain out standing in your field. Great job guys!
     Wolf-Howl
    the must read blog of a true SEO linking artist

    Disclaimer
    The opinions expressed herein are my own personal opinions and do not represent my employer's view in anyway.

    Send mail to the author(s) E-mail

    Total Posts: 71
    This Year: 11
    This Month: 0
    This Week: 0
    Comments: 387

    Sign In

     Wednesday, January 07, 2009
    Wednesday, January 07, 2009 4:19:33 AM (Eastern Standard Time, UTC-05:00) ( )
     

                                                          Find the courage to embrace change and fear mediocrity

    Definitions of misnomer on the Web:

    *******************************************************************

    Can You Define SEO? Well, can you? Yeah I thought it would be tough on ya. Don't worry about it, neither can anyone else.

    If you threatened to take away my plate, I guess I would have to say, while there is really no definition for any misnomer, conventional wisdom would likely dictate that SEO generally means actions taken to ensure a webpage secures superior placement in the organic results of a search engine's returned results page for a specific searched term or phrase. If you don't agree, feel free to leave your definition in the comments,(or anywhere you else you care to).

    So my question is ---- Are you SURE that is really all you want?

    What about sales? traffic? Conversions? Changing people's minds to compliment your own biases? 

    Perhaps it's a truism that just being #1 for a keyword is enough to generate traffic, but I would disagree. I used to see a lot of results on search engines at #1 that I didn't click on. Results with title tags like:
    HOTEL. CHEAP HOTEL. CHEAP HOTEL IN LAS VEGAS

    So perhaps the commonly accepted definition should be more like Webpage Title Optimization, WTO.

    But don't we juice up titles with nice ad copy because traffic is more important than placement? Sooooo doesn't that make us more like traffic generation optimizers? TGO?

    I've got some 17 people in production whose primary purpose is to generate traffic from a pretty wide variety of tactics, some having little if anything to do with search engines. I suppose they would almost HAVE to be called TGOs.

    So what happens when those TGOs DO generate traffic but clients cancel because we did what they said they wanted but they are losing money?

    We have 3 people whose primary function is to analyze logs and develop strategies to be given to production, (the TGOs), to alter negative trends. So I guess those are trend analysis for strategy optimization. TASOs.

    We also built a very simple, yet powerful tool that:

     #1. tracks only referrers that actually get hit and points to the ones that don't at a glance. Why waste time and bandwidth, (which are expenses), when what we really need to know is what is getting hit? Number 1 doesn't matter if it does not generate traffic.

     #2. allows you to deliver highly targeted dynamic content on the fly for increased conversions. So --- this is a content delivery optimization tool? CDO?

    But once the strategy is optimized what do we say to make sure the negative trends identified by the TASOs are reversed? What do you say to whom and where?

    We have 5 fulltime copy writers whose primary function is to write content that incites an emotional response from a human being that results in that human taking a desired action. Content Response Optimizers. CROs 

    And that doesn't even include the research factions of this entire process. So which part of that process is seo and not simply everyday, run of the mill internet marketing?

    I doubt any of my offered acronyms will ever catch on. Probably because they actually describe the actions being taken. Also, please note, out of all of that, we do not have a single resource devoted to optimizing,(or doing anything else to), any search engine. SEO.

    My point is that if all you really want is placement then seo may be a viable option BUT the fee should not reflect a total solution. Search engine placement, traffic generation, marketing research, metrics analysis, ad content delivery, etc. all those things are NOT about search engines, they are about people! Human beings capable of an emotional response. THAT is a total solution.

    Traffic generation is certainly one aspect of a total solution but the rates are not inline with the actual value in a lot of cases.

    Search Engine Spam White Paper

    Almost a decade ago, a certain Alan Perkins wrote what he termed a White Paper called The Classification of Search Engine Spam

    In spite of the fact that the “white paper” was totally unsubstantiated, unproven, unendorsed and quite frankly in my opinion, trite, it still gained a fairly sizeable degree of acceptance online. The gist of the article was, “any technique used that would NOT be used if search engines did not exist is search engine spam”.

    While I never accepted this self-aggrandizing rant as a “white paper”, there is a valid point if it was only worded a little differently.

    Bear in mind, I do not believe there is any such thing as search engine spam other than what search engines themselves promote to place the blame for their own lack of efficiency onto third parties they like to portray as an evil nemesis of fair and unbiased results,(what a load of crap! If you think results are fair and unbiased, you are either blind or crazy).

    BUT, if the gist of “white paper” was more like, “search engines are only a tool and all that really matters is people”, now THAT statement I could wholeheartedly endorse.

    As an illustration I’d like to share an email I received 2 days ago from an online marketer of note in his own right. He happens to be a client of mine and the email he sent me is a very good example of how to do business online without relying on search engine placement directly and instead relying on that human emotional response thing.

    It is the :

    SECRET TO GETTING HI-POWERED LINKS WITHOUT HAVING TO PAY FOR THEM.

     
    I have a very strict policy that we NEVER reveal our clients, their clients, their placements or what techniques we used to get those placements without the client giving me written permission to do so. You’ll see in this letter from Eric Werner of Atlanta Click Advisor that I have such permission. I’ve changed nothing in the letter and it is displayed as it was offered to me.

    *******************************************************************

    Please take this and use it however you’d like. When I wrote it I was thinking that you might like to make it a blog post or part of a blog post, but feel free to add to it, subtract from it, cut it up or not cut it up and use it in any way you’d like or don’t use it at all if it’s not a good fit.

     

    If you’d like to link to my blog in the last paragraph you can use the anchor text ‘adwords marketing’ and point it to www.Atlantaclickadvisor.com although I won’t be slighted in the least if you decide not to.

     

    Every part of this is true and I really wanted to thank you and your staff for everything.

     

    I’ve also attached a version in word format.

     

    Bob,

     

    I just wanted to take a moment to let you know what an impact you've made over the course of the last year. Choosing to use your SEO (Valuable Traffic Generation) services has aided in our tremendous success this year and I can say I honestly don't know what I would have done without the help of your staff. They have been responsive, flexible, and have definitely demonstrated the ability to get the job done.

     

    One of the best case studies I have is for one of the clients you have helped us with. I wanted to share some of the results with you and your readers in case anyone had any question about the quality of real results that you provide.

     

    A couple weeks ago when Google Analytics introduced advanced segmentation I decided to create a segment showing how non-brand related organic traffic has grown throughout the year. I think that the non-brand related traffic is telling because almost all of it is attributable to the work your team did.

     

     

     

     

    Remarkable in itself, of course it begs the question:

     

    Does this traffic convert into new business? I developed this second report which shows that the conversion rate remained steadily positive throughout. The orange line is the conversion rate from non brand related traffic. In my opinion this demonstrates the inarguable value of the service and reinforces your statement about producing valuable traffic rather than just rankings.

     

     

    Beyond all of that I wanted to point out that the personal advice you've given me on multiple occasions has helped to shape my professional development and the way I think about my personal web presence and the web as a whole. Everything you've suggested has paid off more than I would have imagined and I really believe that the web would be a much better place if more people brought the integrity to their work that you bring to yours.

     

    I hope that you continue to be wildly successful this year and continue spread that success to everyone you touch. It has been a great adjunct to my Adwords marketing efforts and I hope that you will turn to me any time you need a referral or a recommendation because I couldn't be happier with the way your services continue to improve.

    ************************************************************


    THAT is an emotional response! So what is the secret?

    THERE IS NO SECRET.  Anyone can do it and it really has very little to do with SEO. It has to do with exceeding the customers’ expectations. It has to do with hard work, commitment to excellence and living the Do Philosophy.

    Do the best job you can do

    Be proud of what you do

    Do what you say you will do

    And charge accordingly

    Is that SEO or is that online marketing?

    So, did any of that help you to define SEO?

     

    Peach Y’all

    The ask the anti-seo seo guru

     

     

     

     

    Never hide your dirty picture books under the bed. That’s always the first place they look!